HIGHER EDUCATION REFORM
AT SYSTEM AND INSTITUTIONAL LEVEL
(THE CASE OF MAKERERE UNIVERSITY)
Justine Epelu-Opio
Deputy Vice-Chancelllor
Makerere University
Kampala, Uganda
ON THE THEME:
From Peril to Promise: How higher Education can deliver
BRITISH COUNCIL INTERNATIONAL SEMINAR TO BE HELD ON 19 TO 23
MARCH 2002 AT BARNET HILL CONFERENCE CENTRE, LONDON
1.0 Background
Makerere University situated 5 kilometers to the north of Kampala
City; the Capital of Uganda in East Africa was founded in 1922 during
the British Colonial era.
From a humble technical school with 14 pioneer students, Makerere
grew into a college by 1935 and became a center for higher education
in East Africa. After the Asquinth Report of 1944, Makerere College
was given the legal status of a University College in 1949 offering
diploma courses of the University of London. In 1953, it started
awarding degree certificates of the University of London. On 29th
June 1963 the relationship with London came to an end, Makerere
University College becoming a Constituent College of the University
of East Africa. The other two colleges were Nairobi and Dar-es-Salaam
University Colleges. On 30th June 1970 the University of East Africa
was dissolved and the three Constituent Colleges became independent
Universities with Makerere assuming the title of Makerere University
on July 01, 1970, awarding its own degrees, diplomas and certificates.
2.0 Challenges
Makerere University was a well organized and functioning University
up to early 1970s. The University was destroyed and virtually stripped
of resources as a result of unconducive economic and political environment
created by military dictatorship of Idi Amin and other subsequent
military regimes.
- The University Council was dominated by government appointees.
The University could not borrow money or sell any movable or immovable
property without the approval of the country's Finance Minister
and Minister responsible for education.
- The political climate of the 1970s coupled with low salaries
drove many of the well qualified academics out of the University
for greener pastures abroad. There was no academic freedom, therefore
objective teaching was not possible. Imprisonment of lecturers,
molestation and elimination by State security agencies mainly
and other persons partly were a common occurrence
- Makerere underwent financial and political crises impacted
on its position as a leading institution of higher learning in
Uganda. Funding to the University was not only reduced, but the
disbursement of funds from the treasury was irregular and either
suspended, or scrapped some items.
- The value of the Uganda shilling was depreciating rapidly.
The University plant was in a pathetic state. Utilities like water,
electricity were frequently cut off for non payment. Research
was almost non-existent. Funds for training were literally scrapped.
Although there were avenues for generating income, it was a politically
sensitive issue. Relations with government deteriorated.
- Financial support could not be sustained due to the negative
growth rate. Priorities of government had changed to military.
Most African governments argued that more budgetary allocations
should be given to defense in order to create an environment that
would attract investment to revamp the economies.
- The following figures show the shift in resource allocation
as a percentage of national budgets of Sub-Saharan Africa over
a 15 year period.
Table 1
|
|
EDUCATION
|
DEFENCE |
HEALTH
|
|
|
1972
|
15.3 |
23.1 |
5.3 |
|
|
1980 |
14.9 |
25.2 |
5.1 |
|
|
1987 |
15.0 |
26.3 |
2.4 |
|
Source: Sub Sahara Africa: from crisis to sustainable growth.
World Bank Report 1987.
- By mid 1980s the government of Uganda was on average funding
approximately 50% of Makerere's financial requirements (Passi 1992).
At the same time student enrolment was on the rise resulting from
both the pressure of the expanded lower levels of education and
the requirement for higher education in order to access formal sector
employment.
- For example, in 1983/84 academic year 61% of the eligible candidates
were admitted under government sponsorship, while in 1990/91 only
35% of the eligible candidates were admitted. The downward trend
continued in the academic year 1999/2000 when only 10.8% of the
16,674 eligible candidates were admitted and sponsored by government.
The expansion of students was unexpected (Table 2).
- Responding to the prevailing situation of inadequate funding
and increased student enrolment, Makerere University was forced
to cut down on research, Staff Development, postgraduate programmes,
equipment, books, science laboratories, chemicals and other teaching
materials. The University was not able to recruit and retain competent
staff. There was high turnover of top management, as well as lack
of donor confidence and assistance. Other essential services like
computing, transport, and telephone were virtually non existent.
There was congestion in lecture rooms resulting in loss of time
during the time of change of classes in and out. Independent study
became difficult with congestion in halls of residence and Library.
- All these developments had a negative impact on the quality of
education offered by Makerere University and lowered its standing
in the public's eye. University/State relations deteriorated as
students and academics were constantly on strike for better pay
and allowances. There was failure by the institution to provide
timely and decisive actions on some of the problems.
- The challenges above left Makerere University with no option
but to reform. The World Bank and the International Monetary Fund
recommended cutting down on expenditures and higher education was
not a priority. Makerere University had to wake up to address the
dwindling government support. There had to be changes in government
University relations.
3.0 Reforms
"We Build for the Future" is the motto of the University
which was known in the sixties as the "Harvard of Africa".
Today after being "Out of the Count" for many years, Makerere
University is in the process of regaining its academic self-respect.
The University has committed itself to expanding, improving and
modernizing the curriculum and its management despite a big reduction
in government funding and the challenges of transforming itself
from a fully funded to a partially private institution: Change the
University vision and mission:
- Old Mission:
To pursue the creation, acquisition, management and transfer
of knowledge; and to fully develop the intellectual capacity of
students through teaching and research; and provision of other
services to the community for accelerated economic, social and
technological development.
- New Vision:
To be a center of academic excellence, providing world-class
teaching, research and service relevant to sustainable development
needs of society.
- New Mission
Makerere University's mission is to provide quality teaching,
carry out research and offer professional services to meet the
changing needs of society by utilizing world wide and internally
generated human resources, information, and technology to enhance
the University's leading position in Uganda and beyond.
- When the National Resistance Movement came to power in 1986,
it had a clear vision and mission and undertook bold pragmatic
political and economic measures. These included liberalization
of the economy, good governance and democratization of management
systems, changes which have encouraged formal and informal interaction
between government and members of the University community. This
has been responsible for the conducive environment which has enabled
Makerere University to carry out the various reforms below:
- Transform from a fully government funded to a partially private
institution.
- Institutional expansion
- Participatory Management
- Improvement and modernization of curriculum and its management.
3.1 Management Systems
With increased demand for University education accompanied with
liberalization of the economy, Makerere University took advantage
to convince government to allow it (University) to effect some reforms
so as to survive. From the informal meetings between government
and University staff and frequent visits by the President and the
Minister of Education, Key University structures are now less prone
to government influence especially to academic related matters.
As a result of the close ties that have developed the University
has been able to implement its liberalization programme with virtually
no interference from government.
3.1.1. Decentralisation
Faced with unexpected and rapid expansion of student enrolment
and diversification of funding partners, Makerere University had
to effect radical changes in administration and management. Power
and responsibilities have been decentralized to faculties/Schools/
Institutes and participatory management has been instituted. Every
faculty/school/ Institute and any other income generating unit/center
for example Halls of residence, must have an executive committee,
appointments and promotion, and finance committee to handle respective
issues. For example, a faculty produces a budget on income and expenditure
of its revenue. The budget is discussed by the Finance Committee
and the Committee ultimately approves the budget. All appointments
and promotions in the university are vetted and approved by the
faculty and appointments committees. Membership to these committees
is by election. No appointment or promotion in academic ranks can
be made without approval of committees. There is open door policy
which has drawn top management closer to the rest of administration
and academic staff. Quarterly management meetings are held with
Deans of Faculties and Directors of Institutes, reports on the developments
in the University are discussed as well as finance, management,
inter-university co-operation and visitors to the University among
others. This has reduced on tensions and mistrust and generated
co-operation. It also gives administration the opportunity to understand
the challenges confronting academics and has enhanced their (administration)
ability to identify the most appropriate strategies for dealing
with these challenges. Students are given opportunity to voice their
concerns, teaching and examinations as well as on any cases of unfair
discrimination by staff. Consultative meetings between staff and
the students generate regular flow of information. Students have
become sensitized and more understanding on the economic challenges
the University faces and the country in general. They now know that
it is inevitable for them to meet some of the costs of their education
at the University. They are represented on some of the committees,
which help them to participate in decisions that affect them. This
has created co-operation with administration and government.
3.1.2. New Universities and Other Tertiary Institutions Act
2001
To many Ugandans, the Makerere University Act of 1970 laid the
ground for the direct political interference and manipulation of
the academic affairs of; the University. The National Resistance
Movement realizing this, and responding to the pressure from staff
and students has taken measures to improve relations with the University.
A new Act of Parliament has been enacted to govern dealings between
Makerere University and other national education institutions of
higher learning and government. Unlike the old Act, the new one
limits powers of government with regard to University decision making.
TABLE 2 - MAKERERE UNIVERSITY STATISTICS OF UNDERGRADUATE STUDENTS
|
YEAR |
NUMBER OF A'LEVEL CANDIDATES |
ELIGIBLE A'LEVEL APPLICANTS |
ADMISSION FIGURES |
ENROLMENT |
DATE OF COMPILATION |
|
GOVERN-MENT |
PRIVATE |
TOTAL |
GOVERN-MENT |
PRIVATE |
TOTAL |
|
1983/84 * |
6589 |
2564 |
1724 |
- |
1724 |
5042 |
- |
5042 |
31/12/83 |
|
|
1984/85 **
|
7372 |
2524 |
1974 |
- |
1974 |
5079 |
- |
5079 |
20/11/84 |
|
|
1985/86 ***
|
8267 |
3359 |
1870 |
- |
1870 |
4208 |
- |
4208 |
27/11/85 |
|
|
1986/87
|
10468 |
3156 |
1585 |
- |
1585 |
4828 |
- |
4828 |
20/2/87 |
|
|
1987/88
|
11674 |
3586 |
1673 |
- |
1673 |
4842 |
- |
4842 |
10/3/88 |
|
|
1988/89 |
13279 |
4050 |
1706 |
- |
1706 |
4731 |
- |
4731 |
23/11/88 |
|
|
1989/90
|
13306 |
4403 |
1720 - |
- |
1720 |
4955 - |
- |
4955 |
10/4/90 |
|
|
1990/91
|
15032 |
5749 |
2205 |
- |
2205 |
5597 |
- |
5597 |
26/11/90 |
|
|
1991/92
|
15944 |
5654 |
2114 |
304 |
2418 |
5819 |
150 |
5969 |
20/12/91 |
|
|
1992/93
|
16690 |
6451 |
2038 |
176 |
2214 |
6538 |
458 |
6996 |
15/2/93 |
|
|
1993/94
|
19601 |
7947 |
2299 |
1062 |
3361 |
6643 |
701 |
7344 |
28/2/94 |
|
|
1994/95
|
21337 |
7472 |
2146 |
1106 |
3252 |
6494 |
1412 |
7906 |
DEC 1994 |
|
|
1995/96 |
21704 |
9332 |
2280 |
2521 |
4801 |
7089 |
2280 |
9369 |
JUNE 1996 |
|
|
1996/97
|
24176 |
11011 |
2273 |
5631 |
7904 |
6710 |
7902 |
14612 |
JUNE 1997 |
|
|
1997/98
|
24639 |
13057 |
2330 |
5919 |
8249 |
6890 |
7477 |
14367 |
JUNE 1998 |
|
|
1998/99
|
28189(March 1998) |
15630 |
2051 |
8168 |
10219 |
6545 |
9497 |
16042 |
APRIL 1999 |
|
|
1999/2000
|
28638(Dec 1998)
|
16674 |
2000 |
12316 |
14316 |
6103 |
14265 |
20368 |
FEBRUARY 2000 |
|
|
2000/2001 |
35708 (Dec) 1999 |
22712 |
1943 |
11350 |
13293 |
6442 |
20351 |
26793 |
APRIL 2001 |
|
Sources: Uganda Examinations Board; and Admissions office,
Makerere University
Note: Students at connected institutions are not included
in the figures.
31stMay, 2001
3.2 Academic Programmes
The University has had to develop demand driven courses responding
to the job market. External degree programmes have been introduced
in the Bachelor of Commerce and Education. There are also new programmes
that reflect the changing trends in the country. These include:
- Gender Studies
- Outreach programmes to benefit Ugandans who may not qualify
to join Makerere University and
- Extension programmes for the rural farmer.
The reforms have encouraged staff to be innovative and creative
and to improve on their delivery system. Resources may be shared,
use of audiovisual Technology e.g. loud speakers, video recorders,
distance education techniques, introduction of the Virtual University.
The University has an affirmative action in place in admission
of students, the disabled, talented sports women and men. Due to
affirmative action on girls, which started in 1993, enrolment of
girls into the University has gone up from 27% in 1990/91 to 40%
in 1999/2000 academic year.
The University has moved away from the rigid term or quarter system
to a semester system, which is more efficient and flexible with
regard to time use. It keeps students busy throughout. While in
the quarter system students took final exams at the end of the academic
year, they now take 2 major exams in each academic year and are
examined on fresh material. Assessment becomes more comprehensive
and vigorous.
Academic audit and quality control system was put in place to ensure
that standards are maintained. In audit students assess teachers
and content of courses. On the other hand, a Quality Assurance Committee
is a standing Committee of Senate that is the supreme academic organ
of the University. Students have been allowed to participate in
the academic affairs of their faculties by participating in the
faculty academic boards and University Senate.
4.0 Linkages
Makerere is currently a role model among African universities,
which have been affected by state funding. The university has reversed
the plant decay of the 1970s and 1980s. International donors for
example NORAD, SIDA/SAREC, SWEDEN, USAID, Carnegie Corporation of
New York, Rockefeller Foundation, to mention a few have started
to come to the assistance of Makerere in institutional building.
Makerere has linkages and collaboration with many institutions
of higher learning nationally, regionally, and the world.
5.0 Achievements
With the private income generated by the paying students the University
has been able to establish a number of funds, namely:-
- In-house pension scheme
- Maintenance Fund
- Staff Development Fund
- Research Fund
Table 3: Day Programme
|
Item |
New Proposal |
|
|
(a) Central Items |
|
|
|
Research |
1% |
|
|
Maintenance |
4% |
|
|
Retirement |
8% |
|
|
Staff Development |
8% |
|
|
Wage Bill |
18% |
|
|
Central Activities |
10% |
|
|
Library |
3% |
|
|
(b) Faculties/Centres |
51% |
|
|
|
100% |
|
Table 4: Evening Programs
|
Item |
New Proposal |
|
|
Research
|
1% |
|
|
Maintenance
|
4% |
|
|
Retirement benefit
|
6% |
|
|
Wage Bill
|
18% |
|
|
Central Activities
|
6% |
|
|
Library
|
3%
|
|
|
Staff Development
|
3% |
|
|
(b) Faculty/Departments |
59% |
|
|
|
100% |
|
Table 5: Postgraduate Programmes (Masters & Ph.dD)
|
Item |
New proposal |
|
|
Faculty/Centre
|
75% |
|
|
Wage Bill
|
9% |
|
|
Central activities
|
6% |
|
|
Library
|
2% |
|
|
Maintenance
|
2% |
|
|
Retirement
|
4% |
|
|
Research |
1% |
|
|
Staff Development |
1% |
|
|
|
100% |
|
Table 6: Accommodation Fees
|
Food ration
|
30% |
|
|
Hall of residence
|
20% |
|
|
Halls SCR
|
5% |
|
|
Dean of Students' Department
|
10% |
|
|
Wage Bill Top-Up
|
15% |
|
|
Central Activities
|
8% |
|
|
Retirement Benefit
|
8% |
|
|
Maintenance |
4% |
|
|
Total |
100% |
|
Table 7: Miscellaneous Revenue
|
Item |
New Proposal |
|
|
Halls of Residence/ |
|
|
|
Collection Centres
|
50% |
|
|
Wage Bill Top-Up
|
10% |
|
|
Central Activities
|
5% |
|
|
Retirement Benefit
|
3% |
|
|
Maintenance
|
2% |
|
|
Hall SCR
|
10% |
|
|
Dean of Students Dept.
|
20% |
|
|
|
100% |
|
Other Collections:
Registration
Examination
Application fees and other Academic Registrar Department's collections
Table 8: Distribution of Revenue Collected
|
Distribution |
Council Approved |
|
|
Registrar's Department |
10% |
|
|
Wage Bill Top-Up |
18% |
|
|
Central Activities |
10% |
|
|
Retirement Benefit |
8% |
|
|
Maintenance |
4% |
|
|
|
100% |
|
As a result of the reforms Makerere University has been able to
record the following achievements:
- the opening of University education to more Ugandans.
- Enhancement of Government/University relations with Government
giving Makerere more autonomy with regard to both teaching and
generation of funds.
- Enhancement of Makerere's internal governance and management
efficiency.
- The ability by government and University to convince students
that cost sharing is an inevitable reality.
- The improvement of the terms and conditions of work for University
dons and administrators.
- The improvement of University learning and assessment mechanisms.
- Making University education more responsive to national needs.
- The improvement of relations between the University administration
on one hand and staff and students on the other.
6.0 Conclusion
The reforms and achievements illustrate the importance of policy
reform. The Government of Uganda has shifted from state control
to state regulation in the governance of the University. This has
created an environment that has enabled the University to regain
its academic self respect.
References
- Kilemi Mwiria (1998) Strengthening Government/University Partnerships
in Africa: The Experience of Uganda's Makerere University. A Study
conducted for the Commonwealth Higher Education Management Services
(CHEMS).
- Passi, F.O.(1992) Implementing Change to Improve the Financial
Management of Makerere University, Uganda. International Institute
for Educational Planning (IIEP), Paris.
- Republic of Uganda (1998) "The Universities and Other
Institutions of Higher Education Act, 2001 Government Printer,
- ampala.
- Ssebuwufu, P.J.M. "Reforming Higher Education: Change
and Innovation (Finance and Governance) (The case of Makerere
University). Paper presented at the Center for African Studies,
University of Florida, Gainesville U.S.A. March 23-25, 2001.
- University of Bergen: A Global Perspective International
Magazine 2001.
|